Peeps Pie is an absurd pie made using leftover Peeps from Easter. This unique Easter dessert is kid-friendly and fun to make. Here’s our Peeps Pie recipe.

Peeps Pie is a ridiculous Easter dessert that your family will never forget. Like lobsters, the Peeps are placed into a saucepan and murdered. What does it taste like? PEEPS heaven. Yum! Here’s how to make your very own Peeps Pie.

Step 1: The Chocolate Base

Add a layer of chocolate pudding to the bottom of a pie shell. Let it cool for at least an hour.

Peeps Pie: Melted Chocolate Base
Peeps Pie: Melted Chocolate Base

Step 2: Melt The Peeps

Place the Peeps into a saucepan, turn the heat on low and murder them. Then feel bad for every lobster you’ve ever eaten.


Peeps Pie: Melt The Peeps
Peeps Pie: Melt The Peeps
Peeps Pie: Melt The Peeps
Peeps Pie: Melted Peeps

NERD NOTE: The ingredients of Peeps are sugar, corn syrup, food dyes, gelatin, and salt.

Step 3: Feel Sad For The Melted Peeps

The Peeps’ cries for help are slowly melted away.

Peeps Pie: Stir Melt The Peeps
Peeps Pie: Stir Melt The Peeps

Step 4: More Chocolate!

Add cream and chocolate chips. Then let the pie cool again.

Peeps Pie: Add Cream & Chocolate Chips
Peeps Pie: Add Cream & Chocolate Chips

Step 5: The Toppings

A grassy knoll is made out of some shredded coconut with green food coloring. Add a crumbled Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Bar to make it even more ridiculous. Finally, add some non-melted Peeps to stand above the grave of their brothers and sisters.

Peeps Pie: Add Your Toppings
Peeps Pie: Add Your Toppings
Peeps Pie: Yummy!
Peeps Pie: Yummy!

Step 6: Eat Your Peeps Pie

Eat it, if you dare. Grab a fork and dig into your Peeps Pie. Just expect a sugar coma and instant cavities.

NERD NOTE: Peeps were created by Russian immigrant Sam Born (1891-1959). Born acquired the Rodda Candy Company in 1953 and innovated their handmade marshmallow chick product with mass production. By the 1960s, Born’s candy company, Just Born, was the “largest marshmallow candy manufacturer in the world.”

Via Image Comics

Related Articles:

Peeps Pie: An Absurd Easter Dessert That Your Family Will Never Forget

Do you like Peeps?

Thank you for the vote!