• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
methodshop

methodshop

tech news, reviews & how to's

  • Trending
  • Latest Stories
  • Fun
  • Culture
  • Learn
  • Tech

Home : Humor : Marshmallow Peeps Pie: An Absurd Easter Dessert That Your Family Will Never Forget

Absurd pie made out of Peeps
This is a ridiculously absurd pie made out of Peeps leftover from Easter. Like lobsters, the Peeps were placed into a saucepan and murdered. What did it taste like? PEEPS heaven. Yum! Here's how to make your very own Peeps Pie.

Marshmallow Peeps Pie: An Absurd Easter Dessert That Your Family Will Never Forget

Marshmallow Peeps Pie is an absurd pie made using leftover Peeps from Easter. This unique Easter dessert is kid-friendly and fun to make. Here's our Peeps Pie recipe.

April 17, 2006 by jayfrankwilson
FacebookTweetPinLinkedIn

Peeps Pie is a ridiculous Easter dessert that your family will never forget. Like lobsters, the marshmallow Peeps are placed into a saucepan and murdered. What does it taste like? Pure PEEPS heaven. Yum! Here’s how to make an Easter Peeps Pie.

Peeps Pie Ingredients List:

  • (1) Box of 3.9 oz chocolate pudding mix ($0.99 per box via Amazon)
  • (1) quart of Half and Half
  • (1) Ready made pie crust ($~2.50 each via Amazon)
  • (3+) Boxes of Peeps. Peeps are sold 10 per box, but feel free to use more Peeps if you have them ($1.50 per box via Amazon)
  • (2) Cups of Shredded coconut flakes (~$3 per bag via Amazon)
  • Green food coloring (~$2 via Amazon)
  • (1) Bag of chocolate chips (~$2.50 via Amazon)
  • (1) Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Bar (~$3 via Amazon)

How To Make Peeps Pie: An Absurd Easter Dessert That Your Family Will Never Forget … #EasterPeeps #PeepsPie #EasterDesserts #recipes #HowTo #kidfriendlycrafts #kidapproved #easyrecipes #Easter
Click To Tweet

Make Chocolate Pudding

  • Make chocolate pudding and then chill

The recipe instructions for your chocolate pudding mix will vary, but most of them just require adding about (2) cups of Half and Half to the mix and whisking it until it solidifies.

After you mix your chocolate pudding, place it in the refrigerator to chill for a few minutes.

Add A Chocolate Base To Pie Crust

Peeps Pie: Melted Chocolate Base
Peeps Pie: Melted Chocolate Base
  • Pour pudding into pie crust

Pour your chocolate pudding into the pie crust. Your goal here is to add a layer of chocolate pudding to the bottom of the pie crust shell. Then let it cool for at least an hour in the refrigerator.

Melt The Marshmallow Peeps

How To Make Peeps Pie: Melting The Marshmallow Peeps
Peeps Pie: Melt The Peeps
  • Melt Peeps in saucepan

Place 2-3 boxes of Easter Peeps into a saucepan, turn the heat on low and murder them. Then feel bad for every lobster you’ve ever eaten.

Melted Marshmallow Peeps
Peeps Pie: Melted Peeps

NERD NOTE: The ingredients of Peeps are sugar, corn syrup, food dyes, gelatin, and salt.

Feel Sad For The Melted Peeps

Peeps Pie: Stir Melt The Peeps
Peeps Pie: Stir Melt The Peeps
  • As your Peeps make the ultimate sacrifice, shed a tear.

The Peeps’ cries for help are slowly melted away as the marshmallow turns into a surgery liquid foam. Yum.

Make The Marshmallow Peeps Mixuture

  • Add cream and chocolate chips to melted marshmallow mixture

Pour the melted Peeps into a mixing bowl and add (1/4) cup of chocolate chips and (1/4) cup of Half and Half. Mix until your mixture solidifies.

Pour The Marshmallow Peeps Mixture Into Your Pie Pan

Peeps Pie: Add Cream &Amp; Chocolate Chips
Peeps Pie: Add Cream & Chocolate Chips
  • Pour the Peeps marshmallow mix into your pie crust. Let it cool.

We are halfway there! Pour your Easter Peeps marshmallow mixture into your pie crust. Don’t overflow it! You need to leave room to decorate the top of your pie.

Then let the pie cool again in the fridge for at least 10 minutes while you prepare the toppings.

Make Shredded Coconut Grass

  • Combine green food coloring and coconut flakes to make coconut grass

Place two cups of shredded coconut into a bowl and slowly add a few drops of green food coloring. Stir the mixture and add more food coloring as needed.

Crumble A Heath Candy Bar

  • Smash up a Heath toffee bar

With your Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Bar still in its wrapper, smash it until it crumbles into small pieces. Then open the wrapper, so it’s ready to pour on top of your Easter Peeps pie.

Decorate Your Easter Peeps Pie With Toppings

Peeps Pie Is An Absurd Pie Made Using Leftover Peeps From Easter. This Unique Easter Dessert Is Kid-Friendly And Fun To Make. Here'S Our Infamous Marshmallow Peeps Pie Recipe.
Easter Peeps Pie
  • Add green coconut grass, crumbled Heath bar and Peeps to the top of your pie.

It’s time to decorate. The grassy knoll is made out of some shredded coconut with green food coloring. Add a crumbled Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Bar in the center to make this Easter dessert even more ridiculous. Finally, add some non-melted Peeps to stand above the graves of their brothers and sisters.

Eat Your Peeps Pie

Eat it… if you dare. Grab a fork and dig into your Peeps Pie. Just expect a sugar coma and instant cavities.

Marshmallow Peeps Pie: The Absurd Easter Dessert

Marshmallow Peeps Pie Is An Absurd Pie Made Using Leftover Peeps From Easter. This Unique Easter Dessert Is Kid-Friendly And Fun To Make. Here'S Our Easter Peeps Pie Recipe.
Easter Peeps Pie: Yummy!

As delicious as Peeps are, it’s almost impossible to eat all of them during the Easter holiday. In my house, we usually have some leftover Easter Peeps that end up going stale. So, if you have some stale leftover Peeps at home, then making an Easter Marshmallow Peeps Pie is a perfect way to use them instead of tossing old Peeps in the trash. Happy Easter!

NERD NOTE: Peeps were created by Russian immigrant Sam Born (1891-1959). Born acquired the Rodda Candy Company in 1953 and innovated their handmade marshmallow chick product with mass production. By the 1960s, Born’s candy company, Just Born, was the “largest marshmallow candy manufacturer in the world.”

Easter Peeps Pie: An Absurd Easter Dessert That Kids Will Love … #EasterDesserts #recipes #HowTo #kidfriendlycrafts #kidapproved #easyrecipes #Easter #EasterPeeps #Peeps #PeepsPie
Click To Tweet

Photos via Image Comics

Related Articles:

  • Funny Resurrection Jokes To Share on Easter Sunday
  • My Butt Hurts: Funny Easter Gifts That Will Make You Smile
  • How To Make A Savory Cheese Pie – Simple But Delicious!
  • Canadian Easter Egg Hunt Turns Violent After Parents Start Stealing Eggs

Related Posts:

  • 12 Famous Casablanca Quotes That We'll Never Forget
    12 Famous Casablanca Quotes That We'll Never Forget
  • Forget Facial Recognition! Your Ear Is Your New I.D.
    Forget Facial Recognition! Your Ear Is Your New I.D.
  • Simon's Cat Easter Bunny Episode: Cat vs. Easter Bunny
    Simon's Cat Easter Bunny Episode: Cat vs. Easter Bunny



FacebookTweetPinLinkedIn
Category: Humor, Food, Holiday Tag: Chocolate, Chocolate chip, coconut, cookies, Cooking, dessert, Easter, Easter Bunny, Heath Bar, lobster, Peeps, Peeps Pie, pie, Sugar, toffee
Previous Post: « iPod Vending Machines
Next Post: Steve Jobs Announces Plans For New Massive 50-Acre Apple Campus Apple Campus »

Sidebar

Trending Now

  • 18 Weird Facts About Sea-Monkeys You Won't Believe Are True, Including Their Connection To The Ku Klux Klan18 Weird Facts About Sea-Monkeys You Won’t Believe Are True, Including Their…
  • 20 Famous People Who Are Members Of The Sleepless Elite20 Famous People Who Are Members Of The Sleepless Elite
  • 7 Pictures Of Naked People Captured By Google's Cameras7 Pictures Of Naked People Captured By Google’s Cameras
  • 25 Colorful Quint Jaws Quotes From The 1975 Blockbuster Film25 Colorful Quint Jaws Quotes From The 1975 Blockbuster Film
  • The 30 Best Caddyshack Quotes That'll Make You LaughThe 30 Best Caddyshack Quotes That’ll Make You Laugh
  • Controversial Nimbus 2000 Vibrating Harry Potter Broomstick Has Parents In An UproarControversial Nimbus 2000 Vibrating Harry Potter Broomstick Has Parents In An Uproar
  • How To Easily Create A PayPal Shipping Label Without InvoiceHow To Easily Create A PayPal Shipping Label Without Invoice
  • The 14 Best National Anthem Performances Of All TimeThe 14 Best National Anthem Performances Of All Time
  • 25 Of The Best Pulp Fiction Quotes From Quentin Tarantino's 1994 Film25 Of The Best Pulp Fiction Quotes From Quentin Tarantino’s 1994 Film
  • 5 Easy Elevator Hacks That Will Help Give You An Express Ride5 Easy Elevator Hacks That Will Help Give You An Express Ride

Categories

Woman With A Dead iPhone Battery

10 Easy iPhone Battery Saving Tips That Will Help You Get Through The Day Without Recharging

Good Morning Vietnam Quotes

The 11 Best Quotes From Good Morning Vietnam

The 1987 film about a military radio station was Robin Williams’ breakout hit. Here are the best quotes from Good Morning Vietnam.

About

MethodShop’s mission is to entertain, inform, and sometimes gross you out. MethodShop has affiliate relationships, so we may get a small share of the revenue from your purchases. Items are sold by the retailer, not by us. All prices are subject to change.

Latest

Good Morning Vietnam Quotes

The 11 Best Quotes From Good Morning Vietnam

Air New Zealand Bunk Beds

Air New Zealand Bunk Beds Coming Soon To Economy Class Passengers

Follow

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
MethodShop Animated Zoom Icon
  • About
  • Submit
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Store

Copyright © 2022 MethodShop · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding Inc.

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
Cookie settingsACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT